WHY SHOULD YOU HAVE ALL THE FUN?
Paul (Dante Colle) is over at his best friend Dave’s house when Dave (Codey Steele) blurts out that he had sex with his stepmom, Sharon (Sheena Ryder)! Paul is shocked and at first, doesn’t believe Dave. They always joked about Sharon having a thing for Dave, but they never actually BELIEVED it. Dave assures Paul that he’s serious – last night he accidentally walked in on Sharon as she was taking a shower. It wasn’t the first time that’s happened over the years but this time something – Dave can’t quite put his finger on what exactly – was different. Sharon just gave him this LOOK, and then one thing led to another.
Paul seems blown away by what Dave is telling him, but also a little jealous. Paul hasn’t done much to hide his attraction to Sharon ever since she joined the family. As they talk more about the sex, Paul’s eyes glint opportunistically as he gets an idea. He suggests that next time it DOES happen… maybe HE could join in too? Dave is surprised by the suggestion and initially refuses. No way! What a fucked up thing to ask! But Paul argues that Dave shouldn’t be the only one who gets to have all the fun – Dave knows he’s always had a thing for Sharon, so as Dave’s best friend, Paul should get a piece of the action too!
For the first time, Dave seems to be seriously considering it, but still hesitates. Paul then reminds him of all the things that HE’S done for Dave over the years, adding ‘You OWE me, man!!’ This is almost enough to convince Dave, but he still expresses doubt, worrying that – even IF Sharon agreed to it – having a threesome with his best friend might be too weird. Paul retorts that it’s certainly no weirder than a guy having sex with his stepmom, and Dave can’t argue with that. He finally relents and agrees to do Paul the favor and ask.
CUT TO TITLE
Later that day, Sharon is relaxing in the living room when Dave and Paul walk in. Sharon welcomes Paul and says she didn’t know the boys were going to be over today, she thought they were spending the evening at Paul’s house. Judging by their excited vibe and the way they are looking at her and dodging the subject, Sharon can see that they obviously have something to say and encourages them to tell her what’s on their minds.
Paul in particular is nervously excited as Dave takes the lead and lays it out for Sharon, tentatively asking her if the boys can share her in a threesome. Sharon is shocked at the suggestion, but her shock is eclipsed by her unhappiness that Dave told Paul their secret. She scolds Dave, telling him that he KNOWS how much is on the line and shouldn’t have told ANYONE. He PROMISED not to. Dave apologizes but swears it’s fine, Paul’s his best friend and wouldn’t tell anyone – he just wants a bit of fun too. But – even though her body language indicates that she is tempted – Sharon declines their offer, insisting that it wouldn’t be a good idea. It’s one thing to risk getting in trouble of being found with her stepson, but if Paul’s parents ever found out what they’d done her reputation would be OVER, she’d be chased out of town!
But the boys urge her on, enticing her with the promise of two energetic young men catering to her every sexual need. Despite her better judgment and wanting to do the right thing, Sharon’s sexual appetite ultimately wins out over any misgivings she has.
After all, two IS better than one!